Buckeye Fudge

This Buckeye Fudge is the perfect combination of chocolate and peanut butter, making a delicious sweet treat with a fun appearance too. Good looks and taste - it's what we all want!

Jump to Recipe (or scroll for photos and riveting information...)
Advertisement - Continue Below
Small stacks of buckeye fudge on a marble board.

What is Buckeye Candy

For all those peanut butter and chocolate lovers, Buckeye Candy is a treat! Buckeye Candy is basically a peanut butter ball that leaves the top circle of the peanut butter fudge visible instead of completely coating it with chocolate. With a bullseye of peanut butter visible at the top, the confection resembles the seed of the Ohio Buckeye Tree. Buckeye fudge is a little different from the traditional candy in that it is made of  sweetened peanut butter and chocolate fudge, and the buckeyes only become visible once you’ve cut into it. 

Peanut butter balls in the bottom of a parchment paper-lined square baking pan.

Easy Way to Make Fudge

My first tip to you is to line your cake pan with parchment paper so that the fudge is easy to remove. The next step is to make the peanut butter balls. It’s quick and easy – just whip the peanut butter with confectioner’s sugar and butter and then shape it into balls. Once the peanut butter balls are in the pan, keep them cold in the refrigerator until you’re ready to coat them with the chocolate fudge. Now, there is a challenging way to make fudge and an easy way to make fudge. We’re going the easy route and using marshmallow crème and evaporated milk to make the chocolate fudge. It takes just about ten minutes start to finish and there’s no candy thermometer required! Pour the fudge over the peanut butter balls and smooth it out with an offset spatula.

Pouring chocolate fudge over peanut butter balls in a square baking dish.

Chilling and Setting Time

The hardest part of making this Buckeye Fudge is waiting for it to set up before digging in. But you must wait. It will take a couple of hours for the fudge to set in the refrigerator. Be patient. 

Chocolate fudge in a square baking pan.

How to Cut Buckeye Fudge

You will need a good thin knife when it’s time to cut the fudge into squares. Have a warm wet towel on hand as well to wipe the knife in between slices. It’s important that the knife be clean with each cut so that you don’t drag chocolate through the peanut butter circles. 

Buckeye Fudge cut into little squares on a marble board.

How to Store Fudge

Fudge is easy to store, but not easy to keep around. But assuming you can keep from eating it all, store fudge in an airtight container for up to two weeks. You can also freeze fudge, however, so feel free to make big batches of fudge and freeze it (again, in an airtight container or freezer bag with the air removed) for a rainy day. Or, get a head start on your holiday gift giving and make your homemade fudge early and add a few pieces to cookie boxes for friends and family.

A stack of buckeye fudge on a marble board.

The Perfect Holiday Gift

Fudge of all kinds makes a perfect gift. It’s really nice to come across a square of fudge in a box of cookies. Or, if you’re feeling ambitious, you could make several different flavors of fudge to create really spectacular boxes of just fudge. I have recipes for basic chocolate fudge, dark chocolate orange fudge, peanut butter fudge, and white chocolate raspberry swirl fudge. Together, these would be an amazing homemade gift for anyone! 

Buckeye Fudge in gift boxes with red ribbon.

Featured Recipe Techniques

More about the skills used in this recipe.

Cooking School
How To Measure Ingredients Properly

Measuring properly can make or break a recipe and there is a right way and a wrong way to measure....View Technique

Advertisement - Continue Below

Buckeye Fudge

  • Prep Time: 25 m
  • Cook Time: 5 m
  • Chilling Time: 2 h
  • Total Time: 2 h 30 m
  • Servings:
    32
    squares

Ingredients

  • ½ cup creamy peanut butter
  • ½ cup unsalted butter divided
  • ¾ cup powdered sugar
  • cups granulated sugar
  • cup evaporated milk
  • 7 ounces marshmallow creme
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 1 cup good quality milk chocolate chips
  • 2 cups good quality semi-sweet chocolate chips
  • 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract

Instructions

  1. Using an electric mixer, whip the peanut butter, ¼ cup of the butter and the powdered sugar until smooth.
  2. Butter or line an 8 x 8-inch pan with parchment paper. Roll the peanut butter mixture into 12 balls and place them in rows in the prepared pan.
  3. In a medium saucepan, combine the granulated sugar, evaporated milk, remaining ¼ cup of butter, marshmallow creme and salt. Bring to a boil and cook for 5 minutes while stirring.

  4. Remove the pan from the heat and stir in the chocolate chips (both milk and semi-sweet), along with the vanilla extract until melted and well combined.

  5. Pour the chocolate mixture over the peanut butter balls in the pan, pouring evenly to cover all the balls. Smooth the fudge with an offset spatula to cover the peanut butter balls. Let the fudge cool to set up. Cut into squares and serve. Store in an airtight container for two weeks or freeze to store longer.
Advertisement - Continue Below
Advertisement - Continue Below
Advertisement - Continue Below

Comments (8)Post a Reply

  1. Please email a step by step to line fudge pan with parchment. How to make those cuts in parchment so fudge is prefectly poured.

    1. Cut the parchment paper about 4 inches longer on each side of your pan. Then fold two creases in the paper to fit the bottom of the pan and another crease on each side to fold and hang over the sides of the pan.

  2. Have not made this yet but excited to do so. But I am confused…as I was reading through, you mention milk in the cooking part and then you add more milk with the chocolate chips. I don’t see in the ingredients but 2/3 cup evaporated milk. Did I overlook something? Also I am assuming that you add the milk chocolate chips when you add the semi sweet ones. I so enjoy your recipes and your knifes are AWESOME!

    1. Hi Mary. The instructions in step 4 were referring to both types of chocolate chip – milk and semi-sweet. I’ve changed the instructions to make it more clear to the reader.
      ML

    1. Hi Carol. Depending on how warm your kitchen is (or your hands, or the ingredients…) the peanut balls can be very soft. Just pop the mixture into the fridge or freezer for a little while and then roll them.

  3. Doesn’t the marshmallow crepe go in the pan after the mixture has cooked, I have always added it just before the chocolate.

    1. I always put the marshmallow creme into the pot with the sugar and evaporated milk, but if you’ve had success your way you could change it up.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *